-
Indian
philosophical systems have no practical relevance to
contemporary problems of life,
-
They
have no effect on the practical life and affairs of the
modern men and women.
-
Some
Indian Philosophical systems even deny 'Ultimate Reality,'
to the Universe, in which we live and have our being.'
-
According
to some western thinkers they have no " No consumer
value." (H.H.PRICE.)
-
That
modern Indian thinkers like Ramakrishna, Vivekanada,
Gandhiji, Tagore, Aurobindo, Vinobhaji, Radhakrishnan and
J.Krishna Murthy, are merely a rehash of the old Vedanta,
they made no advance on the traditional Thought.
REACTIONS
TO WESTERN CRITICS:
EXTREME
ORTHOX Reaction: They refuse to contaminate with the western
methods. They attempt to maintain and preserve the pristine
purity of Indian Philosophical ideas. In the process they have
petrified them. THE ULTRA MODERN Reaction: These are
fascinated/ infatuated with the western ideals. As a result
they are thoroughly uprooted from the past and were completely
absorbed and hypnotised by the western modes of life and
patterns of thought.
THE
RESENTMENT THINKERS: These constitute a creative minority.
They accept the west but are prepared to assimilate the best
out of it. They were shaken by the west but not shattered. The
typical example is Mahathma Gandhiji. His attitude sums up
this middle position. Thus on the western influence he said,
" I do not want my house to be walled n all sides and my
windows to be stuffed. I want the cultures of all lands to be
blown about my house as freely as possible. But I refuse to be
swept off my feet by any."
As Nehru said,
" Change is essential but continuity is also necessary.
The future has to be built on the foundations laid in the past
as well as in the present. To deny the past and break with it
completely is to uproot ourselves and become hapless. It was
the virtue of Gandhiji to keep his feet firmly planted n the
rich tradition of our race and our soil and at the same time
to function on a revolutionary plane.
In
the words of Sri Aurobindho " All that we do to create
must be consistent with the abiding spirit of India, but
framed in to a greater harmonised harmonise rhythm and elastic
to the call of a luminous future… There cannot be a healthy
and victorious survival if we make of the past a fetish
instead of an inspiring impulse."
In
the words of Dr Radha krishnan, the Indian thinkers
"…have carried the fire and the glow and not the
ashes," and exhibited " a remarkable positive
tolerance in actively incorporating all that is best in the
world."
Some of the prominent Orientalists are: MAXMULLER, JACOBI,
VENIS, LANMAN, WARREN WOODS, HUME, STCHERBATSKY, PUSSIN, TUCCI,
EDGERTON MR AND MRS RHYS DAVIDS.WHITNEY, DEUSSEN, KEITH ETC.
They have carried on the work of editing, collating, and
translating almost all-Hindu scripture and made them available
to all.
ANSWERS
TO THE WESTERN CRITICS:
The dominent trends of the contemporary Indian philosophy are
(a) They are centered upon a search of the wide areas of
agreement between the different systems of the east and the
west. They entertainan integral view and sound for a sound
sysnthesis and assimilation and not exclusion.
|